2022– · Based on 2 seasons through August 3, 2025 ·
Karen Pirie follows a young Scottish detective who reopens old murder and kidnapping cases. Karen works with a small police team while facing pressure from bosses, rich families, the media, and suspects who want the past buried. The show mixes serious crime, dark family secrets, sharp jokes, and fast modern police work. The second season gives Karen more authority and a larger case. The show puts a strong female detective at the center and often shows men underestimating her because of her age and sex. Season two gives extra attention to female anger, violence against women, and women working in male-led institutions. The cases also question how money and power can hide the truth for decades. These themes are clear and recurring, but the show remains mainly a crime mystery rather than an activist drama.
Community feedback
Was our 42% Woke rating accurate?
Loading review details…
Breakdown
These are the editorial factors and ratings behind our score for Karen Pirie.
Woke representation / casting
The show gives major roles to a young female detective and a mixed police team. Karen’s leadership is part of the story, but the cast does not appear designed around a strong diversity message. The representation is noticeable but limited.
18%
Woke political dialogue
Characters make repeated comments about Karen being young, female, or too forceful for police work. The dialogue also touches on violence against women and the pressure placed on female anger. These ideas are present, but the show does not often use speeches or direct political slogans.
18%
Identity-driven story themes
Karen’s sex and age affect how other officers, suspects, and powerful men treat her. Season two repeatedly presents female anger as understandable and shows women facing danger, dismissal, and control. The stories also support women proving themselves in male-led workplaces. These themes are important, but crime solving remains the main focus.
43%
Western institutional / cultural critique
The police and media are shown as imperfect institutions that can protect reputations and powerful families. Season two especially criticizes how wealth and status can shape an investigation and hide the truth. The show also questions male authority when men dismiss Karen or try to control the case. It does not broadly attack family life, Christianity, or Western society.
39%
Woke character or canon changes
Not relevant. The series adapts Val McDermid’s modern crime novels without a known identity-based race, gender, or sexuality change to an established character or historical figure.
0%
Anti-woke backlash and complaints
Searches found no meaningful anti-woke campaign or major outlet coverage claiming that Karen Pirie pushes woke politics. A few online viewers disliked the tone or season two story, but those complaints were not about DEI, identity politics, or left-wing messaging.
3%
Creator track record context
Val McDermid has a strong long-term feminist and LGBTQ writing and public advocacy record. Her work often examines violence against women, homophobia, and power. The other stored creators have low scores, and Emer Kenny has no strong activist record tied to this title.
26%
Production
TV Show · 2023
Follows rookie police officers working in Belfast, a city in which being a frontline response cop comes with unique pressures and dangers.
TV Show · 2018
The harrowing true story of the 1993 standoff between the FBI, ATF and the Branch Davidians, a spiritual sect led by David Koresh in Waco, TX that resulted in a deadly shootout…
TV Show · 2022
Under pressure, fraying at the edges. In relentless night-time Liverpool, copper Chris is paired with a rookie. Will they save or destroy each other?
TV Show · 2024
Lone-wolf survivalist Colter Shaw roams the country as a “reward seeker,” using his expert tracking skills to help private citizens and law enforcement solve all manner of…
TV Show · 2020
A 6-year old girl is kidnapped by a mysterious masked man, who demands an unusual ransom. To save his daughter, Dr. Avinash Sabharwal must kill someone!
TV Show · 2019
Erica Shepherd is a brilliant former CIA operative, now known as the most notorious traitor in American history serving life in a Supermax prison.
TV Show · 2020
Hiding a twisted past, a man maintains his facade as the perfect husband to his detective wife — until she begins investigating a series of murders.
TV Show · 2026
Angelo Doyle lives two totally separate lives — fearsome NYC hitman and sleepy upstate Cooperstown photocopier salesman and father.
