In 1974, Finbar Murphy lives quietly in a remote village in County Donegal after years as a paid killer. An IRA bombing sends Doireann McCann and her violent crew into hiding near his home. Finbar wants peace, but he steps back into violence when Doireann’s brother harms a young girl in the village. The story plays like a slow Irish crime thriller with the shape of a Western, and its mood stays grim, quiet, and tense.
The film follows a damaged man who wants to earn a better ending without pretending that his past was harmless. It shows how revenge pulls Finbar and Doireann into the same cycle of bloodshed, even though they defend very different choices. The story gives weight to guilt, mercy, loyalty, and the cost of protecting innocent people. A brief pub scene includes a black African fiddle player, but the main conflict remains a personal fight over crime, terrorism, abuse, and redemption.
Community feedback
Was our 12% Woke rating accurate?
Loading review details…
Breakdown
These are the editorial factors and ratings behind our score for In the Land of Saints and Sinners.
Woke representation / casting
A brief pub scene shows a black African fiddle player among the mostly Irish cast. The character is a background musician and does not lead the story or receive an identity speech. The role may look unusual in a remote Irish village in 1974, but the film gives no clear diversity-first message.
15%
Woke political dialogue
Not present. The film includes IRA talk and arguments about guilt, violence, and personal reasons. It does not use modern identity politics or activist language.
0%
Identity-driven story themes
Not present. The story centers on a killer seeking peace, revenge, abuse, and moral guilt. It does not make race, sex, sexuality, or group identity the main story issue.
0%
Western institutional / cultural critique
Not present. The film shows terrorists, a local crime boss, and a Garda during the Troubles. It does not attack modern Western institutions, family life, men, women, or Christianity.
0%
Woke character or canon changes
Not relevant. The movie is an original crime story with new characters. No established character or source world is changed.
0%
Anti-woke backlash and complaints
Two small X accounts called the brief black musician a forced diversity choice. The supplied X pass found almost no engagement and no wider boycott, review-bomb, or campaign. Mainstream coverage did not report a larger anti-woke dispute.
12%
Creator track record context
Robert Lorenz is cached at 2/100 and both writers are cached at 0/100. Most producers also have low cached scores, while Bonnie Timmermann has a moderate inclusion-focused casting history. This gives the title only a weak creator track record signal.
6%
Production
Movie · 2023
A sheriff tries to keep the peace when a desperate family man violently robs a pill mill with his brother-in-law, alerting an enforcer for the New Orleans mafia.
Movie · 2020
A bank robber tries to turn himself in because he's falling in love and wants to live an honest life...but when he realizes the Feds are more corrupt than him, he must fight back…
Movie · 2018
A gritty crime saga which follows the lives of an elite unit of the LA County Sheriff's Dept. and the state's most successful bank robbery crew as the outlaws plan a seemingly…
Movie · 2025
An unexploded WWII bomb is discovered on a busy construction site in the centre of London. Chaos ensues as the military and police begin a mass evacuation against a ticking clock.
Movie · 2026
As rival gangs, corrupt officials and a ruthless Major Iqbal close in, Hamza's mission for his country spirals into a bloody personal war where the line between patriot and…
Movie · 2016
A troubled veteran gets a chance at redemption by protecting a girl from an assassin after she witnesses a murder.
Movie · 2017
Quan is a humble London businessman whose long-buried past erupts in a revenge-fueled vendetta when the only person left for him to love – his teenage daughter – dies in an Irish…
Movie · 2024
The adoptive son of the Adattu family, Marco, sets off on a ruthless quest for vengeance after his brother is brutally murdered, finding only betrayal, loss and unimaginable…
